| NAME | |
|---|---|
| Chinese Name | 冯礼, 馮禮, Féng Lǐ |
| Nickname | Ye east-gate commander; tunnel traitor (204 AD) |
| Other name | Phong Lễ |
| INFORMATION | |
| Died | 204 |
| Death Reason | Crushed when Shen Pei sealed the tunnel gate during Cao Cao's siege of Ye (204 AD) |
| CAREER | |
| Allegiance | Yuan Shao (until defection); briefly Cao Cao |
| Battles |
|
Biography & Historical Record
Feng Li (冯礼, Phong Lễ) was a Yuan Shao officer who commanded the east gate of Jizhou (Ye city, 邺城) during Cao Cao’s siege of 204 AD. He appears in both the novel and the historical tradition as a cautionary example of how Shen Pei’s harsh discipline could backfire: Feng Li got drunk on watch, was severely punished, defected to Cao Cao, and died leading a tunnel assault that Shen Pei anticipated and sealed with stone. His death closed one of Cao Cao’s early attempts to take Ye before Xu You’s famous plan to divert the Zhang River.
No independent biography survives in Chen Shou; Feng Li is known from the siege narrative preserved in Sanguozhi annotations and Luo Guanzhong’s dramatized Chapter 32. He represents the fracturing morale of Yuan Shao’s heirs’ faction — not a major general, but a gate commander whose resentment altered the siege timeline.
Role in Romance of the Three Kingdoms
Chapter 32 (Yuan Shang and Yuan Tan Struggle for Ji Province; Xu You Proposes Damming the Zhang River): Cao Cao encircles Ye with ramparts and tunnels. Shen Pei enforces strict defense laws. East-gate commander Feng Li, drunk on duty, is harshly flogged; he slips out at night and surrenders to Cao Cao, revealing that the earth inside the Tu Gate (突门) is thick enough for tunneling. Cao Cao sends Feng Li with three hundred men to dig inward by night — but Shen Pei, inspecting the walls nightly since Feng Li’s defection, sees no campfires outside and orders stones dropped to seal the inner gate. Feng Li and all three hundred die buried in the tunnel. Cao Cao abandons tunnel warfare and withdraws to the Huan River until Yuan Shang returns and Xu You later advises flooding the city.
Feng Li (冯礼) — Historical & Literary Timeline
204 AD
East gate commander at Ye
Serves Yuan Shao’s heirs under Shen Pei’s strict garrison command during Cao Cao’s siege of Jizhou.
Chapter 32
Punished for drunken watch
Shen Pei flogs Feng Li for failing patrol; Feng Li defects to Cao Cao with intelligence on the Tu Gate tunnel route.
Chapter 32 (same arc)
Tunnel assault and death
Leads three hundred men through the tunnel; Shen Pei seals the gate with stone — Feng Li and his party perish underground.
204 AD (aftermath)
Siege continues to flooding
Cao Cao shifts strategy; Xu You’s river-diversion plan eventually breaks Ye — Feng Li’s failed tunnel is a prelude to the decisive flood.
For detailed historical records, archives, and official chronicles, explore Battle of Ye on Wikipedia.
Key Relationships
Family
- No kin recorded.
Friends
- Yuan Shao faction officers: Fellow defenders of Ye before Feng Li’s defection — no named allies survive in sources.
Enemies
- Shen Pei (审配, Thẩm Phối): Chief defender who punished Feng Li and anticipated his tunnel assault — direct cause of Feng Li’s death.
- Cao Cao (曹操, Tào Tháo): Besieger who sent Feng Li into the fatal tunnel attack.
Other
- Yuan Shang (袁尚, Viên Thượng) and Yuan Tan (袁谭, Viên Đàm): Yuan Shao’s sons whose succession war frames the Ye siege.
- Xu You (许攸, Hứa Du): Former Yuan officer whose river plan succeeds where Feng Li’s tunnel failed.
- Cao Hong (曹洪, Tào Hồng): Cao general already at the walls when the tunnel operation is launched.
In Novel
Chapter 32
- Feng Li (冯礼, Phong Lễ), east-gate commander (东门守将): Punished by Shen Pei for drunken patrol failure; defects to Cao Cao and advises: "Inside the Tu Gate the earth is thick — tunnel there." Cao Cao sends him with three hundred men at night; Shen Pei seals the gate — "冯礼及三百壮士，皆死于土内" (Feng Li and three hundred braves all died in the earth).
- Shen Pei (审配, Thẩm Phối): "冯礼必引兵从地道而入也" — seeing no enemy campfires, he orders stones to crush the tunnel entrance.
In History
Summary
- Feng Li (冯礼, Phong Lễ) commanded Ye's east gate under Shen Pei in 204 AD, defected after punishment, and died in a failed tunnel assault — attested in siege narratives of the Battle of Ye.
Year: 204 AD
- Cao Cao besieges Ye (冀州); Feng Li's defection and death mirror the novel's Chapter 32 account in annotated tradition.
Historical Record
- Sanguozhi and Pei Songzhi annotations on Cao Cao's Ye campaign; parallel in Zizhi Tongjian for 204 AD.
- Novel: Chapter 32 (Sanguo Yanyi).
COMMENTS (0)